defenseursplus@gmail.com
(+509) 2918 55-59 / 3715-7299
#39A, Rue Baussan, Turgeau, Port-au-Prince, Haiti

An unconstitutional draft electoral decree: Défenseurs Plus calls for a national dialogue around the text

25 May 2026
Administrateur
Press release

The Defenders Plus Collective expresses its deep concerns regarding several provisions of the draft electoral decree currently under discussion. These provisions risk undermining the constitutional principle of independence of the Provisional Electoral Council (CEP) and the fundamental guarantees of civil and political rights enshrined in the Haitian Constitution and international human rights instruments.

The Defenders Plus Collective recalls that the Provisional Electoral Council is, in accordance with article 191 of the Haitian Constitution, an independent institution responsible for organizing and controlling electoral operations throughout the national territory. This independence constitutes an essential guarantee of credibility, neutrality and confidence in the democratic process. However, several provisions of the aforementioned draft decree tend to gradually transform the CEP into a structure under government influence. Indeed, the text provides in particular:

  • In its article 17: the appointment of the Director General of the CEP by decree taken in the Council of Ministers, in place of an Executive Director, appointed by the Electoral Council;
  • In its article 6: the provision of the regulations, procedures and the Code of Ethics of the CEP become enforceable only by Order of the Prime Minister;
  • In its article 12: the imposition on the CEP of the obligation to transmit quarterly and final reports to the Executive;
  • In its article 14.9: that in the event of impossibility of functioning of the Body of Orientation and Decision (OOD), the Director General exercises the powers of the OOD as long as the impediment lasts.

These provisions, among others, dangerously weaken the administrative and institutional autonomy of the Provisional Electoral Council and risk fueling suspicions of political control of the electoral process. The Collectif Défenseurs Plus believes that no serious electoral reform can be sustainable without strong guarantees of institutional independence of the electoral power.

Moreover, the draft decree contains several provisions that undermine fundamental rights and the universal principle of the presumption of innocence. Indeed, certain provisions (art. 56, 76 and 84) make it possible to exclude voters, candidates or electoral agents on the basis of:

  • Judicial or administrative investigations not yet judged;
  • Simple proceedings in administrative law or others;
  • Reports from human rights organizations;
  • Or even the vague notion of persons “ well-known” for certain alleged facts.

The Defenders Plus Collective recalls that Article 11 of the Universal Declaration of Human Rights as well as Article 14 of the International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights enshrine the principle of the presumption of innocence. According to these international standards, anyone accused of an offense is presumed innocent until their guilt has been legally established by a competent court.

The Defenders Plus Collective also recalls that the Haitian Constitution strictly regulates limitations on political rights. Articles 90, 96 and 135 relating respectively to the conditions of eligibility for the functions of deputy, senator and President of the Republic essentially refer to convictions of afflictive and infamous penalties, pronounced by a competent court.

The Constitution in no way provides for political exclusion on the basis of simple accusations, non-judicial reports, ongoing investigations or dubious public reputations. Furthermore, in a democratic state, the fight against corruption, organized crime and impunity remains a necessity. However, this fight must imperatively respect the fundamental principles of the rule of law, in particular: the presumption of innocence, the right to a fair trial, legal certainty, political pluralism and the right to participate in the management of public affairs.

The Défenseurs Plus Collective calls on the transitional authorities, the Provisional Electoral Council, political parties and civil society organizationsto open a broad national dialogue around the decree electoral. This would make it possible to avoid any deviation likely to further weaken the already fragile confidence of the population in the electoral process.

The Défenseurs Plus Collective, a Haitian human rights and electoral observation organization reaffirms that lasting political stability cannot be built on arbitrary exclusion nor on the weakening of the institutional independence of the electoral council.

Done in Port-au-Prince, May 25, 2026

Antonal MORTIMÉ, Av.
Co-Director

Tags
Droits Humains Décret électoral CEP élection

Comments

No comments yet.
Leave a comment